The New York pour report
Best Guinness in New York: Community-Rated NYC Pubs
Pubs returned by New York's live community leaderboard are ranked by average pour rating. Every pub shown has at least five trusted community submissions, and the rating count appears beside its average so you can judge the strength of the result.
Live community data
NYC Guinness leaderboard
Higher averages rank first. Rating count breaks a tie.
- 1Tír na NógNew York City, New YorkLatest rated submission Apr 29, 20254.90Avg rating5 ratings
- 2Old Town BarNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Aug 23, 20264.84Avg rating13 ratings
- 3Jack Doyle'sNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Oct 14, 20254.83Avg rating6 ratings
- 4O'Hanlon'sNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Apr 19, 20254.80Avg rating5 ratings
- 5Pete's TavernNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Feb 21, 20264.70Avg rating5 ratings
- 6Tom and Jerry'sBrooklyn, New YorkLatest rated submission Sep 21, 20254.66Avg rating8 ratings
- 7Sláinte Bar and LoungeNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Mar 23, 20264.64Avg rating5 ratings
- 8The Perfect PintNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Jun 6, 20264.52Avg rating6 ratings
- 9DonnybrookNew York, New YorkLatest rated submission Oct 11, 20254.28Avg rating6 ratings
Transparent by design
How the ranking works
We group trusted community submissions by normalized pub identity and include New York City locations with at least five pour ratings. Pubs rank by unrounded average pour rating, then rating count, then name. “Latest rated submission” is the submission date of the newest counted score that carries a pour rating.
What the scores mean
Community opinion, clearly labeled
These ratings reflect member opinions, not independent inspections. A community pour rating is also separate from Split the G's AI photo score. Sample sizes remain visible, and rankings update as people attach new pour ratings to normalized pub locations.
Help map New York's best pours
Score your attempt, choose the pub where it was served, and leave a pour rating. Your submission helps the next drinker find a better pint.
Frequently asked questions
Which New York pub has the best Guinness?
The live leaderboard above shows the highest-rated eligible New York pub based on current Split the G community ratings. Rankings can change as new ratings arrive, and every listed pub must have at least five ratings.
How are NYC Guinness pubs ranked?
Eligible pubs are ordered by average community pour rating from highest to lowest. Rating count breaks a tie, followed by pub name. Only ratings attached to a normalized New York City pub record are counted.
Are these pubs independently inspected?
No. The rankings reflect Split the G member opinions, not independent inspections. The page publishes the number of ratings beside every average so readers can judge the strength of the sample.
How can I add a Guinness rating?
Open Split the G, photograph your attempt, attach it to the pub where it was served, and add a pour rating. Eligible ratings are included when the leaderboard data refreshes.
Published September 8, 2026. Rankings are generated from live Split the G community data.